Comparative Chemical and Biological Analysis of Wood and Tar Essential Oils from Cedrus atlantica and Juniperus oxycedrus in Morocco
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Wood tar essential oils have garnered attention for their potential therapeutic benefits and industrial applications. However, despite their historical significance, comprehensive analyses comparing artisanal and laboratory-produced variants are notably absent in current literature. Therefore, this research aims to bridge this gap by conducting chemical analysis to identify key constituents in artisanal and laboratory-produced essential oils of wood tar, as well as their antimicrobial and antioxidant activities. The DPPH and FRAP assays were employed to assess antioxidant activity to determine EC50 values. The results of the study revealed the following
major phytoconstituents in the tar: ????-himachalene (30.24%; 22.78%), ????-himachalene (16.06%;14.23%), and ????-Gurjunene (9.69%;7.88%). Similarly, for AJTEO and LJTEO, the major constituents observed were ????-Cedrene (32.85%; 27.89%), Terpinen-4-ol (7.06%;10.13%), and ????- Cedrene (3.51%; 4.85%). In the antimicrobial assessment, laboratory wood tar EO shows stronger inhibition against tested organisms than artisanal wood tar EO. Juniper tar EO was more effective than cedar tar EO. LCTEO displayed potent antioxidant activity, with an EC50 value of 16.09 µg/mL, followed by ACTEO at 17.659 µg/mL. AJTEO and LJTEO exhibited robust antioxidant
effects with EC50 values <1.25 µg/mL. In the FRAP assay, LCTEO demonstrated potent antioxidant activity with a value of 395.66 ± 0.02 µg/mL, while ACTEO showed an EC50 of 532.71±0.053 µg/mL. AJTEO displayed an EC50 value of 293.3±0.012 µg/mL, and LJTEO
exhibited an EC50 of 238.12±0.014 µg/mL. This research compares artisanal and laboratoryproduced wood tar essential oils and their potential for application in pharmacy and cosmetic industries as antimicrobial and antioxidant agents.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
Ninich O, Et-tahir A, Kettani K, Ghanmi M, Aoujdad J, El Antry S, Ouajdi M, Satrani B. Plant sources, techniques of production and uses of tar: A review. J Ethnopharmacol. 2022;285(11):114889.
Ninich O, Et-tahir A, Kettani K, Ghanmi M, Aoujdad J, ElAntry S, Ouajdi M, Burri S, Satrani B. Ethnobotanical knowledge of Moroccans about medicinal Tar. Trop. J. Nat. Prod. Res. 2022;6(3):317–329.
Julin M. Tar production–traditional medicine and potential threat to biodiversity in the Marrakesh region. An ethnobotanical study. Ibg.Uu.Se. 2008;(4):2-22.
Achir M, Maaghloud F, Abdou A, Makssoudi A El, Belbachir A, Adly F, A. El Amrani, Jamaleddine J, Dakir M. Chemical Composition and Antimicrobial Activity of Essential oil from Scales of Moroccan Juniperus phoenicea. UJPAH. 2021;1(30):5–11.
Johnson W. Final report on the safety assessment of Juniperus communis extract, Juniperus oxycedrus extract, Juniperus oxycedrus tar, Juniperus phoenicea extract, and Juniperus virginiana extract. Int. J. Toxicol. 2001;20(2):41–56.
Burri S, Durand A, Alifriqui M, Satrani B, Ghanmi M, Genin D, Ollivier D, Cenzon-Salvayre C, Vaschalde C, Cesarini R. Ethnoarchaeology of Wood Tar Production in the Atlas Mountains (Morocco) Part 1: from Plant to Tar. "Ethnoarchaeology of Fire" International Workshop, 9-12th
fev., 2017. 2017:1.
El Jemli M. Contribution to the ethnobotanical, toxicological, pharmacological and phytochemical study of four Moroccan Cupressaceae: Juniperus thurifera L., Juniperus oxycedrus L., Juniperus phoenicea L. and Tetraclinis articulata L. 2020.
Delgado Robles AA, Burri S, Regert M, Fernandez X. Ethnoarchaeology of wood tar production in the Atlas Mountains (Morocco): Analytical and experimental approach for the chemical characterization of ethnoarchaeological tars. 2017:1.
Çavuş Alan S, Özen R. Türkiye’de Veteriner Hekimliği Folklorunda Yara Tedavisinde Kullanılan Tıbbi Bitkiler: Bir Literatür Değerlendirmesi. Kafkas Universitesi Veteriner Fakultesi Dergisi. 2021;27(5):663–673.
Zahir I, Elazaoui S;, Chakouri M, Naouer B. Ethnobotanical study of Tetraclinis articulata in the region of Beni Mellal - Khenifra. Ethnobot. Res. Appl. 2020;1–22.
Takci HAM, Turkmen FU, Sari M. Effect of cedar (Cedrus Libani A. Rich) tar on bacterial growth. J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. Food Sc. 2020;9(4):805–808.
Jaouadi I, Cherrad S, Tiskar M, Tabyaoui M, Ghanmi M, Satrani B, Chaouch A. Wood tar essential oil from Cedrus atlantica of morocco (Middle atlas) as a green corrosion inhibitor for mild steel in 1 m hydrochloric acid solution. Int. J. Corros. Scale Inhib. 2020;9(1):265–283.
Belliot A. Cade oil, coal tar, ichthyol: dermatological and cosmetic uses. 2007.12-32.
Mazela B. Fungicidal value of wood tar from pyrolysis of treated wood. Waste Manag. Res 2007;27(4):461–465.
Loizzo MR, Tundis R, Conforti F, Saab AM, Statti GA, Menichini F. Comparative chemical composition, antioxidant and hypoglycaemic activities of Juniperus oxycedrus ssp. oxycedrus L. berry and wood oils from Lebanon. Food Chem. 2007;105(2):572–578.
Hajdari A, Mustafa B, Gashi V, Nebija D, Ibraliu A, Novak J. Chemical composition of the essential oils of ripe berries of Juniperus oxycedrus L., growing wild in Kosovo. Biochem. Syst. Ecol. 2014;57:90–94.
Živić N, Milošević S, Dekić V, Dekić B, Ristić N, Ristić M, Sretić L. Phytochemical and antioxidant screening of some extracts of Juniperus communis L.and Juniperus oxycedrus L. Czech J. Food Sci. 2019;37(5):351–358.
Salido S, Altarejos J, Nogueras M, Sánchez A, Pannecouque C, Witvrouw M, De Clercq E. Chemical studies of essential oils of Juniperus oxycedrus ssp. badia. J Ethnopharmacol. 2002;81(1):129–134.
Lindborg M. GC-MS analysis for Polyaromatic Hydrocarbons (PAH) in Moroccan medicinal tars. Uppsala University: Committee of Trop Ecol. 2009;.
Boubekri A, Bentalha A, Atmani W. Adverse Effects of Topical Cade Oil in a Case Report. 2023;10(1):5–6.
Hoummani H, Yacoubi Sahli M, Chebat A, Hida M, Achour S. Four fatal child Juniper tar (cade oil) poisoning. Toxicol. Anal. Clin. 2019;31(2):129–133.
Koruk ST, Ozyilkan E, Kaya P, Colak D, Donderici O, Cesaretli Y, Çolak D, Donderici O, Cesaretli Y. Juniper Tar Poisoning. Clin Toxicol. 2005;43(1):47–49.
Achour S, Abourazzak S, Mokhtari A, Soulaymani A, Soulaymani R, Hida M. Juniper tar (cade oil) poisoning in new born after a cutaneous application. 2011.
Ezzaki IFS, Mtioui N, Khayat S El, Medkouri G, Zamed M, Ramdani MB. Acute Renal Failure Following Poisoning by Juniper Tar ( Cade Oil ). J. Toxicol. Clin. Toxicol. 2020;10(1000442):9–10.
Azizi M, El Kaouini A, Lafkih MA, Bouayed MZ, Bkiyar H, Housni B. A rare case of cade oil poisoning complicated by acute pancreatitis and acute tubular necrosis. Ann. med. surg. 2022;76(April):103562.
Maya BM, Abedini A, Gangloff SC, Kabouche A, Kabouche Z, Voutquenne-Nazabadioko L. A new δ-tocotrienolic acid derivative and other constituents from the cones of Cedrus atlantica and their in vitro antimicrobial activity. Phytochem Lett. 2017;20(May):252–258.
Chauiyakh O, El Fahime E, Aarabi S, Ninich O, Bentata F, Kettani K, Chaouch A, Ettahir A. A Systematic Review on Chemical Composition and Biological Activities of cedar Oils and Extracts. 2023;16:3875–3883.
Rhafouri R, Strani B, Zair T, Ghanmi M, Aafi A, El Omari M, Bentayeb A. Chemical composition, antibacterial and antifungal activities of the Cedrus atlantica (Endl.) Manettiex Carrière seeds essential oil. Mediterr. J. Chem. 2014;3(5):1027–1036.
Al Kamaly O, Saleh A, Al Sfouk A, Alanazi AS, Parvez MK, Ousaaid D, Assouguem A, Mechchate H, Bouhrim M. Cedrus atlantica (Endl.) Manetti ex Carrière Essential Oil Alleviates Pain and Inflammation with No Toxicity in Rodent. Processes. 2022;10(3):581.
Mhirit O. Atlas Cedar through the Network; Silva Mediterranea “Cedre”. Assessment and Perspective. Mediterranean forest. 1999;3(XX):91–100.
UNESCO. Atlas Cedar (Cèdre de l’Atlas) Biosphere Reserve, Morocco. 2018:1–2.
Mohamed D, Hanbali F, Mellouki F, Herrador M, Barrero A, Benharref A, Akssira M. Chemical and antibacterial studies of essential oils of scales and seeds of Cedrus atlantica Endl. J. Nat. Prod. 2014;4 (6)(6):5–18.
Maya BM, Abedini A, Gangloff SC, Kabouche A, Kabouche Z, Voutquenne-Nazabadioko L. A new delta-tocotrienolic acid derivative and other constituents from the cones of Cedrus atlantica and their in vitro antimicrobial activity. Phytochem Lett. 2017;20:252–258.
Aafi. A, Ghanmi. M, Satrani. B, Aberchane. M, Ismailiy. MR, EL Abid. A. Diversity and valorization of the main aromatic and medicinal plants ( AMP ) linked to the Cedrus atlantica' s ecosystem in Morocco. Ann. Rech. For. Maroc. 2009;41(i):190–207.
Saab A, Gambari R, Sacchetti G, Guerrini A, Lampronti I, Tacchini M, El Samrani A, Medawar S, Makhlouf H, Tannoury M, Sleiman Abboud J, Diab M, Kijjoa A, Tundis R, Aoun J, Efferth T. Phytochemical and pharmacological properties of essential oils from Cedrus species. Nat. Prod. Res. 2018;32(12):1415–1427.
Martins DF, Emer AA, Batisti AP, Donatello N, Carlesso MG, Mazzardo-Martins L, Venzke D, Micke GA, Pizzolatti MG, Piovezan AP, Dos Santos ARS. Inhalation of Cedrus atlantica essential oil alleviates pain behavior through activation of descending pain modulation pathways in a mouse model of postoperative pain. J Ethnopharmacol. 2015;175:30–38.
Zrira S, Ghanmi M. Chemical Composition and Antibacterial Activity of the Essential of Cedrus atlantica (Cedarwood oil). J. Essent. Oil-Bear. Plants. 2016;19(5):1267–1272.
Chang KF, Huang XF, Chang JT, Huang YC, Weng JC, Tsai NM. Cedrol suppresses glioblastoma progression by triggering DNA damage and blocking nuclear translocation of the androgen receptor. Cancer Lett. 2020;495:180–190.
Ez Zoubi Y, El-Akhal F, Farah A, Taghzouti K, El Ouali Lalami A. Chemical composition and larvicidal activity of Moroccan Atlas Cedar (Cedrus atlantica Manetti) against Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae). J. Appl. Pharm. Sci. 2017;7(7):030–034.
Ainane A, Khammour F, el Kouali M, Talbi M, Salamat A, Kenz A, Merghoub N, Abba EH, Cherroud S, Tarik A, Ainane T. Chemical Characterization on the Aromatic Composition of Cedrus Atlantica from Morocco in Two Geographical Areas will Break. AOICS. 2018;2(1):134–137.
Ainane A, Khammour, Charaf S, Elabboubi M, Elkouali M, Talbi M, Benhima R, Cherroud S, Ainane T. Chemical composition and insecticidal activity of five essential oils: Cedrus atlantica, Citrus limonum, Rosmarinus officinalis, Syzygium aromaticum and Eucalyptus globules. Materials Today-Proceedings. 2019;13(3):474–485.
Pazinato R, Volpato A, Baldissera MD, Santos RCV, Baretta D, Vaucher RA, Giongo JL, Boligon AA, Stefani LM, Da Silva AS. In vitro effect of seven essential oils on the reproduction of the cattle tick Rhipicephalus microplus. J. Adv. Res. 2016;7(6):1029–1034.
Burri S, Alifriqui M, Bun S-S, Cenzon-Salvayre C, Hakki Cigerci I, Cloarec A, Corbineau R, Robles D, Angelina A, Durand A, El Jemli M, Fernandez X, Genin D, Ghanmi M, Konuk M, Le Maguer S, Liman R, Marmouzi I, Mazuy A, Ollivier D, Ollivier E, Regert M, Satrani B, Yılancıoğlu K. From natural resources to health: Interdisciplinary approach to the production of conifer tars and their medicinal use in the Mediterranean over the long term. In: Archeology News.; 2018:62–69.
Claisse R. The traditional therapeutic system in morocco. J Ethnopharmacol. 1985;13(3):301–306.
Kurt Y, Suleyman Kaçar M, Isik K. Traditional tar production from Cedrus libani A. Rich on the Taurus Mountains in southern Turkey. Economic Botany. 2008;62(4):615–620.
Aberchane M, Fechtal M, Chaouch A, Bouayoune T. Effect of time and distillation techniques on essential oils yield and quality of atlas cedar (Cedrus atlantica M.). In: Annales de la Recherche Forestiere au Maroc. 34.; 2001:110–118.
Satrani B, Aberchane M, Farah A, Chaouch A, Talbi M. Chemical composition and antimicrobial activity of essential oils extracted by fractional hydrodistillation from the wood of Cedrus atlantica Manetti. Acta Bot. Gallica. 2006;153(1):97–104.
Jaouadi I, Cherrad S, Bouyahya A, Koursaoui L, Satrani B, Ghanmi M, Chaouch A. Chemical variability and antioxidant activity of Cedrus atlantica Manetti essential oils isolated from wood tar and sawdust. Arab. J. Chem.. 2021;14(12):103441.
Mansouri N, Satrani B, Ghanmi M, El Ghadraoui L, Aafi A, Farah A. Valorization of the essential oils of Moroccan Juniperus thurifera and Juniperus oxycedrus. Phytotherapy. 2010;8(3):166–170.
Remmal A, Bouchikhi T, Rhayour K, Ettayebi M, TantaouiElaraki A. Improved Method for the Determination of Antimicrobial Activity of Essential Oils in Agar Medium. J. Essent. Oil Res. 1993;5(2):179–184.
Ahmed M, Mezouari A. Chemical composition and Antimicrobial Activity of Accacia tortilis subsp . radiana Tar From Bechar region , Algeria Chemical composition and Antimicrobial Activity of Accacia tortilis subsp . radiana Tar From Bechar region , Algeria Appl. biol. sahar. areas Appl. biol. sahar. areas. 2021:10-26.
Satrani B, Ghanmi M, Mansouri N, Amusant N. Antioxidant properties of essential oils extracted from three species of moroccan junipers. Indian J. Environ. Sci. 2016;11(7):239–247.
Molyneux P. The use of the stable free radical diphenylpicryl-hydrazyl (DPPH) for estimating antioxidant activity. Songklanakarin J. Sci. Technol. 2004;26:211–219.
Sirivibulkovit K, Nouanthavong S, Sameenoi Y. Paper-based DPPH assay for antioxidant activity analysis. Anal. Sci. 2018;34(7):795–800.
Blois MS. Antioxidant determinations by the use of a stable free radical [10]. Nature. 1958;181(4617):1199–1200.
Fekih N. Chemical and biological properties of essential oils from three species of the Pinus genus growing in Algeria. 2015.
Bounihi A. C Phytochemical screening, Toxicological Study and Pharmacological Valorization of Melissa officinalis and Mentha rotundifolia (Lamiaceae).2016:1–199.
Jakubczyk K, Tuchowska A, Janda-Milczarek K. Plant hydrolates – Antioxidant properties, chemical composition and potential applications. Biomed Pharmacother. 2021;142:112033.
Chaouche TM, Haddouchi F, Atik-Bekara F, Ksouri R, Azzi R, Boucherit Z, Tefiani C, Larbat R. Antioxidant, haemolytic activities and HPLC-DAD-ESI-MSn characterization of phenolic compounds from root bark of Juniperus oxycedrus subsp. oxycedrus. Ind. Crops Prod. 2015;64(1):182–187.
Oyaizu M. Studies on Products of Browning Reaction Antioxidative Activities of Products of Browning Reaction Prepared from Glucosamine. Jpn. J. Nutr. Diet. 1986;44(6):307–315.
Tamuly C, Hazarika M, Bora J, Gajurel PR. Antioxidant activities and phenolic content of Piper wallichii (Miq.) hand.-mazz. Int. J. Food Prop. 2014;17(2):309–320.
Ghedadba N, Hambaba L, Ayachi A, Aberkane MC, Bousselsela H, Oueld-Mokhtar SM. Total polyphenols, antioxidant and antimicrobial activities of Marrubium deserti de Noé leaf extracts. Phytotherapy.2015;13(2):118–129.
Derriche R, Messaoudi S, Lahouazi N, Les R. Polyphenol Content and Antioxidant Activity of Essential Oils, Hydrosols and Extracts of Inulaviscosa (L.) Aiton Leaves from Algeria. 2015.
Larbi B. Contribution to the study of Fusarium oxysporum f sp albedinis causal agent of Vascular fusarium wilt of the date palm and means of control.2019.
Terfaya B, Makhloufi A, Mekboul A, Benlarbi L, Abdelouahed D. Antifungal Activity of Juniperus oxycedrus Tar ; Growing Wild in North-west of Algeria. Appl. Biol. Sahar. Areas 2019;1:33–36.
Marongiu B, Porcedda S, Caredda A, De Gioannis B, Vargiu L, La Colla P. Extraction of Juniperus oxycedrus ssp. oxycedrus essential oil by supercritical carbon dioxide: Influence of some process parameters and biological activity. Flavour Fragr. J. 2003;18(5):390–397.
Saab AM, Gali-Muhtasib H, Maietti S, Grandini A, Rossi D, Lampronti I, Gallerani E, Fabbri E, Gambari R. Comparative Antiproliferative activities of wood and seeds essential oils of Juniperus Oxycedrus L. against K562 human chronic myelogenous leukemia cells. J. Essent. Oil Res. 2014;26(4):301–307.
Chalchat JC, Garry RP, Miehet A, Benjilali B. Essential oil
components in sawdust of Cedrus atlantica from Morocco. J. Essent. Oil Res. 1994;6(3):323–325.
Boudarene L, Rahim L, Baaliouamer A, Meklati BY. Analysis of algerian essential oils from twigs, needles and wood of Cedrus atlantica g.manetti by gc/ms. J. Essent. Oil Res. 2004;16(6):531–534.
Fidah A, Salhi N, Rahouti M, Kabouchi B, Ziani M, Aberchane M, Famiri A. Natural durability of Cedrus atlantica wood related to the bioactivity of its essential oil against wood decaying fungi. Maderas: Ciencia y Tecnologia. 2016;18(4):567–576.
Aberchane M, Fechtal M, Chaouch A. Analysis of moroccanatlas cedarwood oil (Cedrus atlantica Manetti). J. Essent. Oil Res. 2004;16(6):542–547.
Haghshenas G, Raouf Fard F, Golmakani MT, Saharkhiz MJ, Esmaeili H, Khosravi AR, Sedaghat S. Yield, chemical composition, and antioxidant activity of essential oil obtained from Ferula persica oleo-gum-resin: Effect of the originated region, type of oleo-gum-resin, and extraction method. J. Appl. Res. Med. 2023;35:100471.
Aberchane M, Satrani B, Fechtal M, Chaouch A. Effect of infection of Atlas Cedar wood by Trametes pini and Ungulina officinalis on the chemical composition and the antibacterial and antifungal activity of essential oils. Acta Bot. Gallica 2003;150(2):223–229.
Nam A-M, Bighelli A, Ghanmi M, Satrani B, Casanova J, Tomi F. Deodarone Isomers in Cedrus atlantica Essential Oils and Tar Oils. Nat. Prod. Commun 2015;10(11):1905–1906.
Kim JR, Perumalsamy H, Shin HM, Lee SG, Ahn YJ. Toxicity of Juniperus oxycedrus oil constituents and related compounds and the efficacy of oil spray formulations to Dermatophagoides farinae (Acari: Pyroglyphidae). Exp. Appl. Acarol. 2017;73(3–4):385–399.
Kačániová M, Galovičová L, Valková V, Ďuranová H, Štefániková J, Čmiková N, Vukic M, Vukovic NL, Kowalczewski PŁ. Chemical Composition, Antioxidant, In Vitro and In Situ Antimicrobial, Antibiofilm, and Anti-Insect Activity of Cedar atlantica Essential Oil. Plants.
;11(3):1–21.
Bailly L. Molecular and isotopic characterization of archaeological tars and resins derived from conifers in a maritime context. 2015:501.
Chalchat JC, Garry RP, Michet A, Peyron L. Chemical composition of natural and empyreumatic oils and extracts from Juniperus oxycedrus and Juniperus phoenicea wood. J. Essent. Oil Res. 1990;2(5):231–236.
Skalli S, Chebat A, Badrane N, Soulaymani Bencheikh R. Side effects of cade oil in Morocco: An analysis of reports in the Moroccan herbal products database from 2004 to 2012. Food Chem Toxico. 2014;64:81–85.
El Hajjouji H, Rahhal R, Gmouh S, Hsaine M, Fougrach H, Badri W. Chemical composition, antioxidant and antibacterial activities of the essential oils of Juniperus phoenicea, Juniperus thurifera and Juniperus oxycedrus. Mediterr. J. Chem. 2019;9(3):190–198.
De Marino S, Festa C, Zollo F, Rusolo F, Capone F, Guerriero E, Costantini S, De Felice V, Iorizzi M. Phytochemical profile of Juniperus oxycedrus ssp. oxycedrus berries: A new monoterpene glucoside and evaluation of the effects on cancer cell lines. Phytochem Lett.
;10:152–159.
El abid A. Review of Research in Morocco in terms of exploitation and valorization of cedar. Ann. Rech. For. Maroc. 1994:627–637.
Nowakowska M. Thermal conversion of tars from biomass gasification. 2014.
Pekgözlü AK, Kuştaş S, Mercan B, Biçer A. Analiza kemijskog sastava katrana od libanonskog cedra. Drvna Industrija. 2017;68(2):107–112.
Abudunia A-M. Phytochemical Study, Biological and Pharmacological Screening of Calendula Arvensis Flowers. 2018.
Ez-Zriouli R, El Yacoubi H, Rochdi A. Study of the sensitivity of certain bacteria –pathogenic human health- to atlas cedar essential oils and antibiotics. E3S Web of Conferences. 2021;319:01032.
Aiboud A. Phytochemical characterization and study of the in vitro and in vivo antidermatophytic action of Cedrus atlantica, Nicotiana tabacum and Allium sativum L tar. 2016.
Bisht A, Jain S, Misra A, Dwivedi J, Paliwal S, Sharma S. Cedrus deodara (Roxb. ex D.Don) G.Don: A review of traditional use, phytochemical composition and pharmacology. J Ethnopharmacol. 2021;279:114361.
Cavaleiro C, Pinto E, Gonçalves MJ, Salgueiro L. Antifungal activity of Juniperus essential oils against dermatophyte, Aspergillus and Candida strains. J. Appl. Microbiol. 2006;100(6):1333–1338.
Okut N, Yildirim B, Ekici K, Terzioğlu Ö, Özgökçe F. Identification of chemical composition and antibacterial properties Juniperus oxycedrus L. Subsp. oxycedrus leaf essential oil. In: Yuzuncu Yil University Journal of Agricultural Sciences.28.; 2018:186–191.
El Jemli M, Kamal R, Marmouzi I, Zerrouki A, Cherrah Y, Alaoui K. Radical-Scavenging activity and ferric reducing ability of Juniperus thurifera (L.), J. oxycedrus (L.), J. phoenicea (L.) and Tetraclinis articulata (L.). Adv. Pharmacol. Pharm. Sci.. 2016.